Which flat is better as per Vastu? Compare two units

4 steps make a Vastu comparison fair: one North check per tower face, the same rooms tagged in each unit, the serious findings side by side, then the score. So which flat is better as per Vastu is usually the one with fewer findings rated 4 or 5, not simply the higher number.
At Vastu16 we read each room under the 16-zone school and the traditional 8-direction school. Our compare flats tool ranks up to 8 checked units. This post teaches the method behind a fair comparison, and how to read the ranking when it surprises you.
Next: your whole home. Rules are general. Your plan is specific. Upload it and see where each room of your home falls under both schools.
Which flat is better as per Vastu: the short answer
Compare like with like, then compare the worst findings, then the scores, then light and heat.
| Step | What you do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Verify North once per tower face | A wrong North can reverse a ranking |
| 2 | Tag the same rooms in every unit | Fewer tags means fewer chances to lose points |
| 3 | List findings rated 4 or 5 side by side | These are the hardest to fix |
| 4 | Compare scores | Separates units with similar findings |
| 5 | Use light, heat and view as tie-breakers | Measurable, and they change daily life |
The compare tool warns you about steps 1 and 2: it flags any unit whose North is not verified and any set of units with different numbers of rooms tagged [1].
Make the comparison fair first
North. Units on different faces of a tower face different ways, so each face needs its own check. The compare tool treats a unit with North set only from a brochure arrow as low confidence, and says a wrong North can reverse the ranking [1].
Same rooms. Tag the main door, kitchen, every toilet, every bedroom, the living room and the balcony in each unit. If you tag a study in one and skip it in the other, the unit with fewer tags looks better than it is.
Exact units. Check unit B-1203 and B-1204, not "Type A" twice. Units on one floor are often mirror images; our post on mirror image flats shows how one layout can score 76 in one unit and 84 in its twin.
Compare the serious defects, then the score
Vastu16's score starts at 100 in each school and subtracts 4 points per severity point for every room rated avoid; the combined score averages the two schools [1]. So one finding rated 5 of 5 costs 20 points in that school, and so do a 3 of 5 and a 2 of 5 together. Several mild findings can cost as much as one serious one.
That is why we list serious findings first. A finding rated 4 or 5, such as a toilet in the north-east or a kitchen at the centre, is usually structural in a flat and hard to move [1]. Mild findings often have free remedies. Our list of serious Vastu defects has every reading rated 4 or 5.
The compare tool ranks by combined score, then by fewer serious findings, and shows each unit's serious count and its three worst findings [1]. Read those columns before the rank.
When the two schools disagree on your units
The schools disagree often. The 16-zone school uses 16 zones of 22.5 degrees and the 8-direction school uses 8 zones of 45 degrees, and their rules differ [1]. A west toilet, for example, is rated avoid 2 of 5 by the 16-zone school and good by the 8-direction school.
A practical order:
- Agreed serious findings weigh most. If both schools rate a placement 4 or 5, it is not a matter of school.
- Split findings are a school's view. Note them, do not ignore them.
- A family preference for one school is a fair tie-breaker. Say which school you used.
Our guide to the 16-zone and 8-direction schools explains where they come from and why they differ.
Light, heat and view as tie-breakers
When two units are close on Vastu, use what you can measure on a visit.
Heat. West and east walls take more summer sun than north walls. The Eco-Niwas Samhita 2024 weights west walls at 1.156 and north walls at 0.659 for heat gain, for latitudes under 23.5 degrees N (Table 49) [3]. The IIT Bombay energy handbook, modelling an air-conditioned building with one glazed wall, found that in warm climates glass facing south-west gives the highest annual cooling load of the four orientations it tested [4].
Light. The National Building Code 2016 treats any part of a room more than 7.5 m from a window as unlit (Part 3, cl. 20.1.2, Note 2) [2]. A deep living room with one window will be darker than its floor area suggests.
View and noise. Note what faces the main windows and how loud the room is with them open.
Worked example: units A and B
Two 2 BHK units in one project, both with North verified on a satellite map and the same six rooms tagged. We ran both through our engine [1].
| Unit A | Unit B | |
|---|---|---|
| Findings rated 4 or 5 | Toilet in the NE, 5 of 5 in both schools | None |
| Other findings | Second toilet in the W: 2 of 5 (16-zone), good (8-direction) | Kitchen in the SW, 3 of 5 in both; toilet in the E, 2 of 5 in both; toilet in the W, 2 of 5 (16-zone), good (8-direction); door in the S, 2 of 5 (8-direction), neutral (16-zone); master bedroom in the SE, 2 of 5 (8-direction) |
| Score, 16-zone | 72 | 72 |
| Score, 8-direction | 80 | 64 |
| Combined | 76 | 68 |
The compare tool ranks unit A first, by score. Our method asks you to look first at the serious column: unit A has a north-east toilet rated 5 of 5 in both schools, and unit B has none. If that one finding matters to your family, unit B is the better choice despite the lower score. If it does not, and the mild findings in unit B bother you more, unit A wins. Both readings are honest; the decision is yours.
Checklist
Your comparison method, step by step
- Verify North for each tower face on a satellite map.
- Check each unit's own plan and save it with its unit number.
- Tag the same rooms in every unit.
- Write the findings rated 4 or 5 for each unit in one column.
- Prefer the unit with fewer agreed serious findings.
- Use the score to separate units with similar serious findings.
- Break a tie with west glass area, morning light and noise.
Our checklist before buying a flat covers what to note on each visit.
What is tradition and what is fact
Tradition
- Zone ratings and severities: Vastu16's rule table, 16-zone and 8-direction schools.
- The schools disagree on several placements, such as a west toilet.
Physical fact
- West walls carry a higher heat-gain weighting than north walls: Eco-Niwas Samhita 2024, Table 49, latitudes under 23.5 degrees north.
- Glass facing south-west gives the highest cooling load in warm climates: IIT Bombay and MNRE handbook, 2006.
- Parts of a room more than 7.5 m from a window are treated as unlit: NBC 2016, Part 3, cl. 20.1.2.
- Score arithmetic: 100 minus 4 points per severity point, per school (Vastu16 method).
Where Vastu16 fits
The free check lets you check each shortlisted unit's floor plan under both schools, save it under its unit number, and compare up to 8 units with their serious findings shown. It does not weigh price, light, view or floor, and it does not pick a unit for you.
Questions people ask
How do I compare two flats by Vastu?
Verify North for each tower face, tag the same rooms in every unit, then list the findings rated 4 or 5 side by side. The unit with fewer serious findings usually comes first. Use the score to separate units with similar findings, and light and heat to break a tie. Check each unit's own plan, not the unit type.
Is a higher Vastu score always better?
No. The score adds up every finding, so several mild ones can cost as much as one serious one. In our worked example, unit A scores 76 with a toilet rated 5 of 5, and unit B scores 68 with nothing rated higher than 3. Which you prefer depends on whether that one serious finding matters to you.
What if the two schools disagree about my units?
Show both readings rather than picking one. If a unit's serious findings are agreed by both schools, give them more weight. Where one school rates a room avoid and the other good or neutral, treat it as a school's view. If your family follows one school, give that school's reading more weight and say so.
Related posts
Mirror image flats: why the same plan reads differently
Mirror image flat Vastu: two units with the same plan, flipped, can get different readings. How mirroring moves rooms between zones, and how to check.
Vastu checklist before buying a flat: 20 site checks
A 20-point Vastu checklist for the site visit: North, entrance, kitchen, toilets, balcony, light and the documents to ask the builder for.
Corner flat Vastu: two open sides, light and zones
Corner flat Vastu: a corner unit has two outside walls. How Vastu reads its openings and zones, and the light and heat trade-offs to check first.
Sources
- Vastu16 methodology and rule table (internal)
- NBC 2016, Volume 1, Part 3 Development Control Rules and General Building Requirements
- Eco-Niwas Samhita (ENS) 2024, Energy Conservation and Sustainable Building Code (residential)
- Handbook on Energy Conscious Buildings (Nayak and Prajapati, IIT Bombay and Solar Energy Centre, MNRE, pilot edition May 2006)


